employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

MINDEF Singapore

Is this your company?

MINDEF Singapore reviews

3.8

63% would recommend to a friend

(904 total reviews)
avatar

Ng Eng Hen

86% approve of CEO

62% positive business outlook

MINDEF Singapore has an employee rating of 3.8 out of 5 stars, based on 904 company reviews on Glassdoor which indicates that most employees have a good working experience there. The MINDEF Singapore employee rating is in line with the average (within 1 standard deviation) for employers within the Government and public administration industry (3.6 stars).

Reviews by job title

904 reviews
3.0
Nov 23, 2020
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

You are entrusted with the sacred duty of keeping Singapore ahead, honestly, there is probably no other company like this. Unique opportunity. You have access to details that are secret and this can help you learn new things about the world. The job is very secure and there is no danger of pay stagnating. Promotion is guaranteed given enough years in service.

Cons

No. 1 gripe is that the management style is excessively deferential and hierarchical. Analysis is driven by what is most likely to get cleared. Analysts do not learn how to think and analyze issues systematically, but rather to present info in an anodyne airtight way. This is so the Ministers and internal management have nothing negative (not necessary anything positive) to say. Far from being a think tank with secret info, more like a monastery on a forgotten Tibetan hilltop. Not much chance to learn new things outside of civil service lens. Technology? Forget about it. Expertise is not valued unless you are a senior officer. You need to "prove your worth" first by going through the same path as your seniors. Internal postings are becoming less opaque, but often "who you know" rather than "what you know". In summary, if you have a vision or a desire to change things, you need to slowly spend decades here growing your empire and coterie of like-minded individuals. Unless you are lucky enough to be talent spotted by a senior officer and catapulted to the forefront. It used to be a relatively scholar-blind place. But new management values trying to recruit PSC scholars so they aggressively recruit scholars and give them more opportunities than the regular officers. Also is far more likely to hire mid-career officers such as SAF officers or other civil servants, and give them better pay and roles. If you want to join, join as a mid careerist.

1.0
May 11, 2016
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Offers more competitive salary than other ministries/ statutory boards. Decent bonus - minimum 3 months (for average performer) and can go as high as 5 months. Regular salary reviews (once a year) and they are either in percentage increment or one time bonus. "Iron rice bowl" - the organisation finds it very difficult to dismiss an employee. Non profit organisation - minimal stress, and very good work life balance where employees can easily take leave.

Cons

No career progression (you are stuck with the same job title for years). Difficult to be promoted as the managers/ senior managers tend to work for 10-20 years. The company culture values personnel who work for long and based on their loyalty instead of job performance. Many of the higher management are uniform personnel and their position cannot be fulfilled by non-uniformed personnel (eg. DXO). Due to the presence of two types of personnel (uniformed and non uniformed), there is unbalanced focus more towards the uniformed ones. Supervisors who are uniformed personnel do not understand the HR benefits or promotion criteria for the non uniformed personnel. Skills acquired from the job are not transferrable and definitely made it difficult to go to private sector in the future.

2.0
Sep 13, 2014
Recommend
CEO approval
Business Outlook

Pros

Sense of purpose as Nexus' aim is to increase commitment to defence and increase "soft power" of the SAF. Meaningful social activities organized during festive seasons. Good work-life balance.

Cons

Steep Hierarchy. Almost everybody bent backwards daily to outwardly please the boss and to create ample chances for them to show that they are boss. Before a meeting began, for example, the team would reserve the center chair at the meeting table for the boss to seat at when he came in (boss would always be the last to enter the meeting room). When the meeting started, since the boss would typically have very high power distance, everyone attending a discussion would concur with whatever the boss said or proposed. Blind Spots. Since whatever the bosses said was regarded as correct, this creates an organization where groupthink is prevalent. A boss could propose any random idea which he feels is a great idea, and then we would all have to implement his idea. After a meeting, we would all busy ourselves with finding selective data and research which would validate the boss' idea. Nobody dared to veto for fear of appearing disrespectful and being black-listed. The Boss is "God". The deeply-entrenched practice of elevating the bosses to an almost god-like level was evident in our monthly management meetings. The monthly meeting was called "Prayers", which implied that we the employees had to go to the meeting to seek the god's advice and blessings for proposed plans. At a particular time in each month, we would all be scrambling like mad to prepare flashy and sophisticated-looking powerpoint slides for Prayers. Lack of Streamlined Workflows. What hindered my ability to work effectively was the lack of streamlined workflows. For example, when I wanted to write a simple outreach email to principals, my email had to be edited about 12 times over two weeks before it could be sent out. (In my previous job, I only had to clear important emails an average of one time with my boss. Currently, I don't even have to clear any high-level emails with my boss). Such a speed and habit of working was unacceptable for me because it signaled a low level of productivity in Nexus, and I was not able to harness my full effectiveness. Low Transferable Skills to Private Sector and Other Government Agencies. As the work which DXOs do tends to be highly specialized in terms of its knowledge domain, it is hard for any DXO to get a next job after staying in MINDEF for too long. DXOs do not gain any functional skills which are recognized by the private sector as well. When I was preparing to exit Nexus and was going for job interviews, the stop-dead question that I inevitably got at interviews was "Nexus? Oh, it's part of MINDEF? What do you do exactly?". Not long after my answer, the interviewer would politely say "Ok we will call you if we find you suitable". DXOs are Second-Class to Military Personnel. DXOs in MINDEF are treated as second-class to military personnel. This is evident from the vast number of military personnel who are parachuted to be department and team heads in DXO outfits, and also from the fact that DXOs have no planned/guided career progressions (unlike the military equivalent of the tour of duty). Should a DXO want to excel, he/she would have to plan, anticipate and fight very hard for opportunities against military personnel and DXO scholars. Highly-Regimented Culture. At one point, my supervisor shared feedback with me that a military colleague whom I normally worked with wanted to convey the message for me not to call him by name, but that I should address him by rank and name instead. While I regarded military colleagues as fellow professionals and strived for a healthy level of informality, most military colleagues would prefer a strict code of regimentation to be adhered to - right down to explicitly acknowledging their military rank in all written and verbal communication. Therefore I found myself expanding energy trying to please the highly-regimented culture much more than being able to direct my attention to real work. Final Sharing to Anyone Considering a DXO Job or Career. If for whatever reason, you would like to apply to work in Nexus or MINDEF, I would suggest that you ensure you have a sound exit strategy first. Once you get into Nexus or MINDEF, you would most likely be stuck there for a while because the real working world would not want you so much thereafter. We know that in a fast-moving economy, solid transferable skills and alternative career choices are the currency of success in today's workplace.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 904 Reviews

Glassdoor has 983 MINDEF Singapore reviews submitted anonymously by MINDEF Singapore employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if MINDEF Singapore is right for you.